TFIM — Transverse-Field Ising Model

Overview

The one-dimensional transverse-field Ising model is the canonical exactly-solvable quantum many-body system with a quantum phase transition. QAtlas solves it via the Jordan-Wigner transformation followed by Bogoliubov-de Gennes (BdG) diagonalisation; PBC additionally requires parity-projected (NS+R) sectors.

Hamiltonian

\[H = -J \sum_{i} \sigma^z_i \sigma^z_{i+1} - h \sum_{i} \sigma^x_i\]

(σ-convention: eigenvalues ±1.) Parameters: Ising coupling $J$ (default 1.0), transverse field $h$.

Phase diagram:

  • \[h/J < 1\]

    : ferromagnetic ordered phase ($\langle \sigma^z\rangle\neq0$)
  • \[h/J = 1\]

    : quantum critical point (Ising CFT, $c=1/2$)
  • \[h/J > 1\]

    : quantum paramagnetic phase ($\langle \sigma^z\rangle = 0$)

Universality: the critical point belongs to the 2D Ising universality class via the quantum-classical mapping (1+1D quantum ↔ 2D classical).


Coverage Matrix

The table below reflects TFIM_registry.jl @register entries. ✅ marks a native fetch method; "conversion" means routed through another granularity by core/registry.jl.

QuantityOBCPBCInfinite
Energy {:total}✅ BdGconversion
Energy {:per_site}conversion✅ BdG (NS+R)✅ closed-form
FreeEnergy✅ NS+R
ThermalEntropy✅ NS+R
SpecificHeat✅ NS+R
MagnetizationX✅ NS+R
MagnetizationZ0 by Z₂✅ Pfeuty $m_z = (1-(h/J)^2)^{1/8}$
SusceptibilityXX✅ variance✅ NS+R✅ Kubo (Calabrese-Mussardo)
SusceptibilityZZ✅ WickN_proxy=80
CorrelationLength$\xi = 1/(2\lvert h-J\rvert)$
MassGap$\Delta = 2\lvert h-J\rvert$
XXCorrelation {:static}✅ Pfaffian✅ proxy
XXCorrelation {:connected}
XXCorrelation {:dynamic}
ZZCorrelation {:static}
ZZCorrelation {:connected}✅ (= static, Z₂)
ZZCorrelation {:dynamic}
ZZCorrelation {:lightcone}
ZZStructureFactor✅ static + dynamic (proxy)
VonNeumannEntropy✅ Peschel✅ CC (T=0 crit/gapped + T>0 crit)
RenyiEntropy(α)✅ Peschel✅ CC
EnergyLocal
MagnetizationXLocal {:equilibrium}
MagnetizationXLocal {:quench}✅ closed-form k-integral (#145)
MagnetizationZLocal
SpontaneousMagnetization✅ alias of MagnetizationZ
CentralCharge✅ 1/2 (critical) / 0

YY observables (YYCorrelation, SusceptibilityYY, MagnetizationY) are intentionally not implemented — the σʸ JW string makes OBC contractions expensive; tracked as Tier 3 in issue #110.


Boundary Conditions

QAtlas supports three boundary conditions for the TFIM, each with different physical content:

BCfetch argumentBdG sizePhysical setting
OBCOBC(N)$2N \times 2N$ (numerical)Open chain, $N$ sites, $N-1$ bonds
PBCPBC(N)parity-projected NS+RRing of $N$ sites, $N$ bonds
InfiniteInfinite()$k$-integralThermodynamic limit, PBC $N \to \infty$

OBC: the BdG matrix is diagonalised numerically. Boundary effects include the Z₂ tunneling splitting in the ordered phase and the $O(1/N)$ boundary correction at criticality. See gap analysis below.

PBC: the JW transformation produces a fermion parity factor that splits the partition function into Neveu-Schwarz (anti-periodic) and Ramond (periodic) sectors with both signs of the parity projector (LSM). QAtlas evaluates all four (NS±, R±). The Ramond k=0 zero mode at criticality is handled explicitly.

Infinite: the quasiparticle dispersion $\Lambda(k) = 2\sqrt{J^2 + h^2 - 2Jh\cos k}$ is integrated over the Brillouin zone using Gauss-Kronrod quadrature (QuadGK.jl).


v0.17 / v0.18 Highlights

Status: Unstable (v0.18.x)

The PBC thermodynamics, Z-axis Infinite surface, XX static / connected via Pfaffian, Calabrese-Cardy entanglement at Infinite, and dynamic structure-factor helpers are new in v0.17–v0.18. Method signatures, granularity conventions, and keyword-argument names (N_proxy, ω, , beta) may change in v0.19. Call sites should use the public QAtlas.fetch(model, quantity, bc; ...) interface and must not depend on internal helpers (the _tfim_* prefixed functions).

1. PBC free-fermion thermodynamics (v0.17)

Jordan-Wigner with a fermion parity factor splits $Z$ into Neveu-Schwarz and Ramond sectors with both parity-projector signs. QAtlas sums all four sectors (NS+, NS−, R+, R−); at the critical point the R-sector $k=0$ zero mode is handled explicitly.

m  = TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.5)
β  = 1.0
QAtlas.fetch(m, FreeEnergy(),       PBC(8); beta=β)
QAtlas.fetch(m, MagnetizationX(),   PBC(8); beta=β)
QAtlas.fetch(m, SusceptibilityXX(), PBC(8); beta=β)
QAtlas.fetch(m, MassGap(),          PBC(8))

References: Lieb-Schultz-Mattis (1961); Sachdev §4.2. Source: TFIM_pbc_thermal.jl.

2. Z-axis Infinite — Pfeuty closed forms (v0.17)

QuantityFormula
MagnetizationZ (= SpontaneousMagnetization)$m_z = (1 - (h/J)^2)^{1/8}\;\;(h<J)$, else 0
CorrelationLength$\xi = 1/(2\lvert h-J\rvert)$ (Inf at criticality)
SusceptibilityZZOBC large-$N$ proxy via N_proxy kwarg
ZZStructureFactorstatic $S_{zz}(q)$ from Fourier of large-$N$ correlator
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.5), MagnetizationZ(),    Infinite())  # ≈ 0.985
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.7), CorrelationLength(), Infinite())  # 1/0.6 ≈ 1.667

Source: TFIM_zaxis.jl.

3. XX static / connected via Pfaffian Wick (v0.18)

OBC static $\langle\sigma^x_i\sigma^x_j\rangle$ is the $t=0$ limit of the existing dynamic Wick contraction, evaluated as a real Pfaffian over the Majorana covariance block. The connected variant subtracts $\langle\sigma^x_i\rangle\langle\sigma^x_j\rangle$. Infinite uses the OBC large-$N$ proxy (N_proxy kwarg).

m = TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.7)
QAtlas.fetch(m, XXCorrelation{:static}(),    OBC(8); beta=Inf, i=3, j=5)
QAtlas.fetch(m, XXCorrelation{:connected}(), OBC(8); beta=Inf, i=3, j=5)
QAtlas.fetch(m, XXCorrelation{:static}(),    Infinite(); i=3, j=5, N_proxy=80)

YY OBC remains unimplemented (issue #110, Tier 3). Source: TFIM_xx_static.jl.

4. Calabrese-Cardy Infinite entanglement (v0.18)

The thermodynamic-limit von Neumann and Rényi entropies are evaluated in closed form via the Calabrese-Cardy formula. Coverage:

Region$T = 0$$T > 0$
Critical (h = J)$S = (c/3)\,\log(2\ell)$$S = (c/3)\,\log\!\left[(2\beta/\pi)\sinh(\pi\ell/\beta)\right]$
Gapped (h ≠ J)$S = (c/6)\,\log(2\xi\,\sinh(\ell/\xi))$error (deferred — see issue #110)

with $c = 1/2$ for Ising. The Rényi $\alpha\neq 1$ prefactor is $(c/12)(1 + 1/\alpha)$.

QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), VonNeumannEntropy(), Infinite(); ℓ=50)
# ≈ (1/6) log(100) — critical T=0

QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.5), RenyiEntropy(2.0),   Infinite(); ℓ=20)
# Rényi-2, gapped CC

QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), VonNeumannEntropy(), Infinite();
             ℓ=20, beta=4.0)
# critical T>0

Source: TFIM_cft_entanglement.jl.

5. Dynamic structure factor at Infinite (v0.18, proxy)

ZZStructureFactor at Infinite() is router-dispatched on the optional ω keyword:

  • ω === nothing → existing static proxy (Fourier of static correlator)
  • ω::Real → dynamic proxy (time-evolution + Fourier of dynamic correlator)

Two helpers are exported for analytic post-processing:

  • tfim_quasiparticle_dispersion(model, k) -> Float64 — closed-form Bogoliubov dispersion $\Lambda(k)$.
  • tfim_two_spinon_dos(model, ω; q_total = 0.0) -> Float64 — two-spinon density of states at fixed total momentum, used to identify the continuum threshold.
m = TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0)
QAtlas.fetch(m, ZZStructureFactor(), Infinite(); q=π/2, ω=1.5)
tfim_quasiparticle_dispersion(m, π/2)
tfim_two_spinon_dos(m, 1.5; q_total=0.0)

Closed-form form-factor expansion (Calabrese-Mussardo) is not yet implemented — issue #110. Source: TFIM_infinite_dynamics.jl.


Ground-State Energy

Statement

The ground-state energy of the OBC TFIM with $N$ sites is

\[E_0 = -\sum_{n=1}^{N} \frac{\Lambda_n}{2}\]

where $\{\Lambda_n\}$ are the positive eigenvalues of the $2N \times 2N$ BdG matrix. At finite temperature $\beta = 1/(k_B T)$:

\[\langle H \rangle(\beta) = -\sum_{n=1}^{N} \frac{\Lambda_n}{2} \tanh\!\left(\frac{\beta \Lambda_n}{2}\right)\]

Derivation

The TFIM is solved exactly via the Jordan-Wigner transformation, which maps the spin chain to free fermions after a Kramers-Wannier duality step. The full derivation — including why the duality is needed for the $\sigma^z\sigma^z$ convention and the explicit construction of the BdG matrix — is given in the calculation note JW-TFIM-BdG.

The result is a $2N \times 2N$ real symmetric BdG matrix whose eigenvalues come in $\pm\Lambda_n$ pairs. The positive eigenvalues $\Lambda_n > 0$ are the quasiparticle energies, and the total energy at inverse temperature $\beta$ is:

\[\langle H \rangle = -\sum_n \frac{\Lambda_n}{2} \tanh\!\left(\frac{\beta \Lambda_n}{2}\right)\]

Thermodynamic limit

For PBC in the $N \to \infty$ limit, the quasiparticle dispersion is $\Lambda(k) = 2\sqrt{J^2 + h^2 - 2Jh\cos k}$, and the energy per site becomes a $k$-integral evaluated by Gauss-Kronrod quadrature (QuadGK.jl).

References

  • P. Pfeuty, "The one-dimensional Ising model with a transverse field", Ann. Phys. 57, 79 (1970) — exact solution of the 1D TFIM.
  • E. Lieb, T. Schultz, D. Mattis, "Two Soluble Models of an Antiferromagnetic Chain", Ann. Phys. 16, 407 (1961) — JW transformation for spin chains.
  • S. Sachdev, Quantum Phase Transitions, Cambridge University Press (2011), Ch. 5 — pedagogical treatment.

QAtlas API

m = TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.5)

# Ground-state energy (β → ∞), OBC, N=16 — total
E₀ = QAtlas.fetch(m, Energy{:total}(), OBC(16))

# Finite-temperature total energy
Eβ = QAtlas.fetch(m, Energy{:total}(), OBC(16); beta=2.0)

# Thermodynamic limit (PBC, N→∞) — per site
ε  = QAtlas.fetch(m, Energy{:per_site}(), Infinite(); beta=2.0)

Verification

Test fileMethodWhat is checked
test_tfim_gap_closure.jlDense ED via build_tfim$E_0^{\text{ED}} = E_0^{\text{BdG}}$ for $N = 4, 6, 8$
test_universality_cross_check.jlBdG at $N = 200$$E_0/N \to -4J/\pi$ at $h = J$

Finite-Temperature Observables

Statement

At inverse temperature $\beta$ and for $N$ sites (OBC), the following quantities are computed from the BdG spectrum $\{\Lambda_n\}$:

QuantityFormulaType
Free energy$F = -\frac{1}{\beta}\sum_n \ln\!\left[2\cosh(\beta\Lambda_n/2)\right]$FreeEnergy
Entropy$S = \beta(\langle H \rangle - F)$ThermalEntropy
Specific heat$C_v = -\beta^2\,\partial \langle H \rangle / \partial \beta$SpecificHeat
Mag. (X)$\langle\sigma^x\rangle$ from the Bogoliubov occupationMagnetizationX
Susc. (XX)Variance of $\sum_i \sigma^x_i$ (OBC); Kubo at InfiniteSusceptibilityXX

PBC ⇒ all of the above with parity-projected NS+R sums (v0.17).

Derivation

All quantities follow from the free-fermion partition function. For independent modes with energies $\Lambda_n$:

\[\mathcal{Z} = \prod_n 2\cosh\!\left(\frac{\beta\Lambda_n}{2}\right)\]

The free energy is $F = -\beta^{-1}\ln\mathcal{Z}$, and all other thermodynamic quantities follow from $\beta$-derivatives.

References

  • S. Sachdev, Quantum Phase Transitions (2011), Ch. 5.3.
  • QAtlas: src/models/quantum/TFIM/TFIM_thermal.jl, TFIM_pbc_thermal.jl — full implementation.

QAtlas API

m = TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.5)
β = 2.0

F  = QAtlas.fetch(m, FreeEnergy(),       OBC(16); beta=β)
S  = QAtlas.fetch(m, ThermalEntropy(),   OBC(16); beta=β)
Cv = QAtlas.fetch(m, SpecificHeat(),     OBC(16); beta=β)
Mx = QAtlas.fetch(m, MagnetizationX(),   OBC(16); beta=β)
χ  = QAtlas.fetch(m, SusceptibilityXX(), OBC(16); beta=β)

# PBC variants (NS+R) — v0.17
F_pbc = QAtlas.fetch(m, FreeEnergy(),     PBC(16); beta=β)
Mx_pbc = QAtlas.fetch(m, MagnetizationX(), PBC(16); beta=β)

# Infinite — closed-form k-integrals
F_inf  = QAtlas.fetch(m, FreeEnergy(),     Infinite(); beta=β)
Mx_inf = QAtlas.fetch(m, MagnetizationX(), Infinite(); beta=β)

Verification

Test fileMethodWhat is checked
test_TFIM_thermal.jlDense ED ($N \leq 10$)Exact match of $F$, $S$, $C_v$, $M_x$ vs. ED
test_TFIM_pbc_thermal.jlNS+R vs. ED ($N\leq8$)PBC parity-projected sums match exact ring partition

Energy Gap and Quantum Phase Transition

Statement

The many-body energy gap $\Delta = E_1 - E_0$ equals the smallest BdG quasiparticle energy $\Lambda_{\min}$. In the thermodynamic limit:

\[\Delta = 2|J - h|\]

At the critical point $h = J$, the gap closes as $\Delta \sim N^{-z}$ with dynamic exponent $z = 1$.

Physical Context

  • Ordered phase ($h < J$): for OBC with finite $N$, the "gap" seen by exact diagonalisation is actually the Z₂ tunneling splitting between $|\!\uparrow\cdots\uparrow\rangle$ and $|\!\downarrow\cdots\downarrow\rangle$, which is exponentially small in $N$. This is distinct from the physical excitation gap $\Delta \approx 2(J - h)$.
  • Critical point ($h = J$): $\Delta \sim \pi/N$ (finite-size gap for OBC).
  • Disordered phase ($h > J$): $\Delta \approx 2(h - J)$, the paramagnetic gap.

References

  • P. Pfeuty, Ann. Phys. 57, 79 (1970), Eq. (3.6).
  • S. Sachdev, Quantum Phase Transitions (2011), §5.5.

QAtlas API

# Infinite chain — closed form Δ = 2|h − J|
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=0.3), MassGap(), Infinite())   # 1.4
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), MassGap(), Infinite())   # 0.0  (critical)

# OBC finite-N — smallest positive BdG eigenvalue
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), MassGap(), OBC(32))      # ≈ π/N

# PBC finite-N — smallest excitation across NS / R sectors (v0.17)
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), MassGap(), PBC(16))

Verification

Test fileMethodWhat is checked
test_tfim_gap_closure.jlDense ED ($N = 4$$12$)Gap shrinks with $N$ at $h = J$
test_tfim_gap_closure.jlEDOrdered-phase gap is Z₂ tunneling ($< 10^{-3}$ for $N=6$)
test_universality_cross_check.jlBdG ($N = 200$)$\Delta \approx 2\lvert h-J\rvert$; $\nu z = 1$ from log-log regression

Entanglement Entropy at OBC (Peschel)

Statement

At the critical point $h = J$, the entanglement entropy of a contiguous block of $\ell$ sites in an $N$-site OBC chain obeys the Calabrese-Cardy formula:

\[S(\ell) = \frac{c}{6}\ln\!\left[\frac{2N}{\pi}\sin\!\left(\frac{\pi \ell}{N}\right)\right] + s_1\]

with central charge $c = 1/2$ (Ising CFT). See the Calabrese-Cardy method page for OBC vs. PBC prefactors and extraction procedure.

Physical Context

The TFIM is a free-fermion system after Jordan-Wigner transformation, so the reduced density matrix on a contiguous block of $\ell$ spins is Gaussian and its von Neumann (or Rényi) entropy is computable in $O(\ell^3)$ from the Majorana covariance matrix restricted to that block (Peschel's correlation-matrix method). QAtlas exposes this directly via VonNeumannEntropy and RenyiEntropy at OBC — no Kramers-Wannier detour is needed, because the internal $\sigma^x$-string JW convention puts the Majorana pair $(\gamma_{2i-1}, \gamma_{2i})$ on spin site $i$ directly, and the JW transformation factorises across any contiguous bipartition up to a parity factor on $A$ that commutes with $\rho_A$ (Fagotti-Calabrese 2010).

Full derivation of the per-mode entropy formula $S_A = \sum_k s_2(\nu_k)$ from the Gaussian-preservation theorem, the Majorana-covariance canonical form, and the contiguous-block JW factorisation: Peschel correlation-matrix method.

References

  • P. Calabrese, J. Cardy, J. Stat. Mech. 0406, P06002 (2004), Eq. (19).
  • I. Peschel, J. Phys. A 36, L205 (2003), Eq. (9).
  • G. Vidal, J. I. Latorre, E. Rico, A. Kitaev, Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 227902 (2003).
  • M. Fagotti, P. Calabrese, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 227203 (2010).

QAtlas API

# Ground-state von Neumann, ℓ = N/2 at criticality
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), VonNeumannEntropy(), OBC(100); ℓ=50)
# ≈ 0.7256  ((c/6) log((2N/π) sin(πℓ/N)) + s_1, c = 1/2)

# Thermal von Neumann at β = 1
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), VonNeumannEntropy(), OBC(100); ℓ=50, beta=1.0)

# Rényi α ≠ 1 (v0.18)
QAtlas.fetch(TFIM(; J=1.0, h=1.0), RenyiEntropy(2.0), OBC(100); ℓ=50)

Verification

Test fileMethodWhat is checked
test_TFIM_entanglement.jlPeschel vs. full ED SVDMachine-precision agreement for every $\ell$ at $N = 10$, three $(J, h)$ points
test_TFIM_entanglement.jlPeschel ($N = 100$)Extracted $c \approx 0.5$ within 5% at criticality
test_TFIM_entanglement.jlPeschelSymmetric $S(\ell) = S(N-\ell)$, area law away from criticality
test_TFIM_renyi.jlPeschel α-traceRényi $\alpha = 2, 3$ matches small-$N$ ED
test_TFIM_cft_entanglement.jlCC at InfiniteCritical T=0/T>0 and gapped T=0 closed forms vs. analytic
test_entanglement_central_charge.jlED ($N \le 14$)$c_{\text{extracted}} \approx 0.5$ within 10%

Coverage by Reference

Physical / methodological backing of each fetch surface:

  • BdG (OBC ground / thermal): Pfeuty 1970.
  • PBC parity projection (NS+R): Lieb-Schultz-Mattis 1961; Sachdev §4.2.
  • Peschel correlation matrix (entanglement, OBC): Peschel 2003; Calabrese-Cardy 2004; Fagotti-Calabrese 2010.
  • Calabrese-Cardy (entanglement, Infinite): Calabrese-Cardy 2004,
  • Pfaffian Wick (XX static / connected): Wick 1950 + free-fermion Σ contraction.
  • Pfeuty closed forms (Z-axis Infinite): Pfeuty 1970 (spontaneous magnetisation, correlation length).
  • Two-spinon DOS / dispersion helpers: standard Bogoliubov dispersion + convolution; see Calabrese-Mussardo for the form-factor programme (not yet implemented).

Connections

  • Universality: Ising universality class$c = 1/2$, $\nu = 1$, $z = 1$.
  • Classical counterpart: IsingSquare — the 1+1D TFIM maps to the 2D classical Ising model via the quantum-classical correspondence ($\beta_{\text{classical}} \leftrightarrow$ imaginary time).
  • Disordered version: Random TFIM — the Fisher infinite-randomness fixed point at $[\ln J]_{\text{avg}} = [\ln h]_{\text{avg}}$.
  • E8 spectrum: E8 universality — perturbing the critical TFIM at $h = J$ by a longitudinal field $\lambda \sigma^z$ is the $\Phi_{(1,2)} = \sigma$ magnetic perturbation of the Ising CFT. Zamolodchikov (1989) showed the resulting massive field theory remains integrable and its eight stable particles realise the $E_8$ mass spectrum.

API

Modules = [QAtlas] at the end of index.md already pulls docstrings for the exported observable types and TFIM helpers (tfim_quasiparticle_dispersion, tfim_two_spinon_dos); no @autodocs block is needed here.


<!– ATLAS:HUBS:START – auto-generated by docs/atlas/generate.jl. Do not edit by hand; edits between these markers are overwritten on next regen. –>

Verified hubs

In the Verified Atlas, this model registers 53 hubs (quantity / BC pair). The badge column shows the R1 assurance level; click a hub link to see the exact verify(...) calls, references, and corroboration mechanism.

QuantityBCAssuranceCards
CentralChargeInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p3
CorrelationLengthInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p1
CriticalExponentsInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
EnergyInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p4
EnergyOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p9
EnergyPBC🔵 coherent2
EnergyLocalOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
FidelitySusceptibilityInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p2
FidelitySusceptibilityOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
FreeEnergyInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p3
FreeEnergyOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p2
FreeEnergyPBC🟢 corroborated-at-p2
GGEValueInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
LoschmidtEchoInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p1
LoschmidtEchoOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
MagnetizationXInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p2
MagnetizationXOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p2
MagnetizationXPBC🟢 corroborated-at-p2
MagnetizationXLocalInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
MagnetizationXLocalOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
MagnetizationYOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
MagnetizationZInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p2
MagnetizationZLocalOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
MassGapInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p11
MassGapOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
MassGapPBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
RenyiEntropyInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
RenyiEntropyOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p3
SpecificHeatInfinite🔵 coherent2
SpecificHeatOBC🔵 coherent2
SpecificHeatPBC🔵 coherent1
SpontaneousMagnetizationInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p2
SusceptibilityXXInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
SusceptibilityXXOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
SusceptibilityXXPBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
SusceptibilityYYOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
SusceptibilityZZInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
SusceptibilityZZOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
ThermalEntropyInfinite🔵 coherent2
ThermalEntropyOBC🔵 coherent2
ThermalEntropyPBC🔵 coherent1
VonNeumannEntropyInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
VonNeumannEntropyOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p4
XXCorrelationInfinite🟢 corroborated-at-p2
XXCorrelationOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
XXStructureFactorInfinite🔵 coherent1
XXStructureFactorOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
YYCorrelationOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
YYStructureFactorInfinite🔵 coherent1
YYStructureFactorOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p1
ZZCorrelationOBC🟢 corroborated-at-p3
ZZStructureFactorInfinite🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0
ZZStructureFactorOBC🟠 uncorroborated-but-feasible0

<!– ATLAS:HUBS:END –>